Kelleys Island, OH Real Estate

Kelleys Island OH Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Kelleys Island OH Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Kelleys Island: $460,425  County Average: $301,303

Average Taxes in Kelleys Island: $1,046  County Average: $1,223

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Kelleys Island: $186  County Average: $141

Average Walkscore in Kelleys Island: 9  County Average: 27

Average Year Built in Kelleys Island: 1965  County Average: 1961

Average Days on Website in Kelleys Island: 280  County Average: 144

Kelleys Island OH Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in Kelleys Island OH

Harbor Lane Kelleys Island Kelleys Island Twp.
Kellys Island Ki Park Long Point
Pheasant Cove Quarry Condo Sunset Point
Sweetbriar Village of Kelleys Island Village-Kelleys Island
Water St Sweetbriar

Areas in Kelleys Island OH

Kelleys Island Lake Erie Islands Milan

Most Popular Listing

Popular Kelleys Island Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Kelleys Island Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Kelleys Island Real Estate

Listings in Kelleys Island


the Kelleys Island state park and nature reserve is a short walk north on division street featuring the glacial grooves, sandy beach, boat ramp, dock, mooring, campgrounds, and nature trails. over 800 acres of Kelleys Island is designated nature preserves. notable site features include the abundance of mature trees (pines, walnut, poplar, apple, pear, mulberry, cedar, and lilac. the limestone basement walls from the former monarch winery manager's home create an ideal outdoor room. don't miss this rare opportunity just one mile from downtown....

* if you're looking for a beautiful island getaway home, here is your chance...

.72 acre, wooded lakefront lot with 110 + feet of beach...

Start living the lake erie island lifestyle today! new prices on these island parcels located on the southeast side of the island...

Unique opportunity to own a piece of Kelleys Island...

Spectacular views overlooking the quarry pond from this second story, 2 bedroom, 2 full bath unit...

centrally located between the Kelleys Island ferry boat line and downtown Kelleys Island. lot is located across the street from Kelleys Island ball park and pavillon and municipal buildings. short walk to island churches and ki winery! do not let this once in a lifetime opportunity get away!...

Built in 1857, this side gable home reflects new england folk tradition...

***this is the hidden gem 100x143 lot has lake-views and 3 bedroom septic system installed...

short distance to island ferry service to put-in-bay and Kelleys Island. schedule your private showing today!...

private sewage system must be approved by erie county. Kelleys Island has regular passenger and vehicle ferry service....

The 3 lots are being sold as 1, this way you may build your island retreat...

private sewage system must be approved by erie county. Kelleys Island has regular passenger and vehicle ferry service and a paved air strip....

Location, location, location! prime commercial lot in downtown kelley's island...

One of a kind two family home in Kelleys Island historic district...

close to lakeview park, bay point, marblehead shopping and dining and Kelleys Island ferry. ideal location in a truly unique and picturesque neighborhood. quartz kitchen counters, open floor plan....

it is located within 10 - 16 miles by boat or ferry of port clinton, bass island, put-in-bay, marblehead/lakeside, and Kelleys Island, and 21 miles of cedar point in sandusky. enjoy a lifestyle of relaxation, boating, fishing, golf, shopping, and hiking, walking, or snowmobiling in the park systems....

Wonderful cottage w/wrap around porch to relax with friends & family...

this home is being sold move in ready, totally turn key, bring your bag and enjoy your new Kelleys Island home. secluded location directly on lake erie. incredible views abound inside and out....

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Janet Beane
12198 Pearl Rd.
Strongsville, OH

Other Locations